Life After Leaving the Convent: 5 Things You May Still Be Navigating

I've been out of religious life for 15 years now, which is wild to write. I've also been talking recently with a woman who's been home for about 10 years, and it got me thinking about some of the things that continue to come up for us years after leaving the convent. Life after leaving religious life can bring its own set of challenges, even when you've been home for years and have already established somewhat of a normal looking life back in the world.

I consider the initial transition back into the world as like Phase One - finding a place to live, getting a job, buying lay clothing, growing back your hair, socializing with peers, and hopefully finding a therapist or someone to hold space for you. This Phase can last anywhere from 1-5 years I would say. It’s over when you have a lot of those themes locked in or settled and are living a somewhat “normal” life, yet you still don’t feel normal. (Hint: you may never feel normal, let’s be honest.) I probably wrapped up Phase one by year 2 - my transition was pretty easeful comparatively speaking.

In Phase Two, you find yourself still getting tripped up by things, still navigating post-convent themes you didn’t realize would follow you into this next chapter.

Having been out for 15 years myself, I've had plenty of time to reflect on my own experience. And while everyone's experience is different, there are a few areas that I think are worth talking about. These aren't necessarily things I've figured out. Some I'm still navigating currently at age 45. But I thought it might be helpful to share a little of my experience and hopefully offer some companionship to those of you who are also several years out.

If you have more topics that are current for you, please leave a comment and let us know.

1. Rebuilding Your Identity After Leaving Religious Life

I was in religious life for almost eight years, so the identity shift was a big one for me. When you're a sister in a particular religious order, that identity comes with a whole set of characteristics, personality traits, skills, and ways of living and operating. There's the culture of the order, the expectations, the rhythms of daily life, and the role you occupy within that community.

And then you leave. You take off your habit and veil, return to your baptismal name, and suddenly you're back in the world as just a woman living her life.

In some ways, I actually enjoyed the process of getting to know myself again. But it did take time. I remember in those first few years wondering things like, What do I even like to do in my free time? That might sound like a small thing, but when you've spent years living a very structured life, with your time and activities largely determined by the community, having weekends entirely to yourself can feel like a whole new experience.

So I started experimenting. I went to the library and started reading books for fun. Non-Catholic books, even! I tried different art projects, took a ceramics class, made jewelry, stamped cards, and played around with watercolor. I started going on walks and hikes by myself, finding parks to explore, and figuring out what I actually enjoyed doing when nobody else was deciding how I spent my time.

It was almost like having to figure out who I was as an adult in the world at age 30. And I think that's an important part of the identity shift. It's not just about no longer being Sister So-and-So. It's about discovering who you are outside of that identity and figuring out who you want to be in your life after the convent, and even once you find one version of that, it can definitely continue to shift as the years go on. Such is my case for sure.

Even being a former nun can become an identity in itself. There was a period of time when I didn't particularly want to tell people about my background. I think I needed some space from that narrative and just wanted to be a woman in the world without that backstory being part of how people perceived me.

Now, I'm bringing it more to the forefront again through my YouTube channel and writing. I think both experiences have their place. Sometimes you need to take some space from your former identity to figure out who you are now, without constantly defining yourself in relation to who you used to be.

Do you still struggle to feel like you have a solid identity as a woman in the world?

2. Finding Friendship and Belonging After Leaving the Convent

This was probably one of my bigger struggles that lasted years after leaving. I really struggled to find my people.

I was living in South Jersey and working as a teacher, and I tried a number of different things to meet people and make connections. There were Catholic young adult groups in Philadelphia that were much more active than anything locally, so I would drive over there fairly regularly. I also participated in a local prayer group with other young adults. We did things during Lent and Advent for a year or two. I even tried a Spanish meetup in Philadelphia because I wanted to practice speaking Spanish.

I was pretty comfortable showing up to things by myself. I think partly because I was already in my 30s, but also because being around young Catholic people and going to events was something I'd been doing for years, since college. It wasn't particularly intimidating. But I never really clicked with anyone on a deeper level. I met people, participated in things, and tried to find my place, but nothing really stuck.

When I eventually left teaching and worked at a juice bar, I met some wonderful people there. It was my first secular job, and I genuinely loved a lot of the people I worked with. But more than half of them were about 10 years younger than me, and I naturally fell into more of a mama-bear role with them. The people closer to my age were mostly men, and while we got along and had a great rapport, those weren't necessarily friendships that extended beyond work.

After about five years in New Jersey, I was feeling pretty frustrated with the lack of meaningful connections. And that was actually part of why I moved to Arizona in 2016. Yes, my work situation was also changing, but I was hoping that moving to Phoenix might give me a better opportunity to find my people. I had become much more of a nature girl and wanted to find people who enjoyed hiking, being outdoors, yoga, and things like that.

And I did find more of a regular friend group in Phoenix than I ever had in New Jersey. We gathered, did fun things together, and shared life for those years. I look back on that time fondly. But those friendships were also somewhat seasonal. I've been back in New Jersey for six years now, and aside from keeping in touch with one of those girls, most of those friendships didn't continue once I moved away and I was okay with that.

I think that's something I've come to accept about friendship and belonging. I'm also quite an introvert, so my need for friendship and connection is probably different from someone who thrives on having a large social circle. I have one lifelong best friend whom I met in college, and she was also a nun with me. We're still best friends, and that relationship fulfills a big piece of my need to be seen, understood, and supported.

I've also found that Nate and I do really well sharing our lives together. We have dance friends and people we enjoy spending time with, but neither of us needs or particularly desires a large, frequently socializing friend group. Between Nate, my best friend and the community we found in salsa dancing, the need to “find my people” has eased. But that took me 11 years, so it can take time and a few moves!

Still, I think the struggle to find friendships after leaving the convent is real. Having experienced the depth of commitment and community that comes with religious life, I think we can sometimes find ourselves looking for a similar depth of connection in the outside world. And that isn't always easy to find.

I don't have a solution for this one. I'm not even someone who has a close-knit group of friends today. But I do think it's worth acknowledging that finding your people after religious life can take time, and sometimes your experience of belonging looks very different from what you once had. For me today, it looks like a Salsa Studio, not a church or prayer group. Spiritual homes and connections can be found in the most unexpected places!

3. Grief and Loss After Leaving Religious Life

Grief is another thing that can stay with you after leaving religious life, although my experience of it was a little different. I was SO ready to leave when I left. I didn't even come home wearing my habit. I left it at the convent and came home in sports clothes. I had reached a point where I felt oversaturated. I couldn't breathe. So, for me, leaving was much more like taking a deep breath of fresh air finally than experiencing a significant sense of loss as others may have felt.

But there were things I missed. One of the biggest was the beauty of the liturgy. I was the liturgist throughout my religious life, so the liturgical seasons, the Liturgy of the Hours, Mass, the singing, the hymns, and the solemnity of the celebrations were a very tangible part of my experience. There's something really special about living the Church year as a sister within a religious family that celebrates the liturgy beautifully.

I missed the Advent hymns, the Easter celebrations, the particular rhythms of the seasons, and the way everything came together. Going through the Church year in a regular suburban Catholic parish fell flat in comparison.

I also experienced another kind of loss over time: the loss of relationships. For a few years after leaving, I tried to maintain contact with some of the sisters I had been close to. We exchanged emails, and I visited the convents in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, DC and Harlem a few times for feasts and other occasions.

But eventually, those relationships became pretty one-sided. My life was changing and growing in all these new ways, and when I shared those things with the sisters, they didn't seem particularly engaged. They would mostly tell me about their parish life and the familiar rhythms of the community. It started to feel like we didn't have much in common anymore. My life would increase and change, theirs was the same year after year.

I wasn't necessarily upset about it, but I realized I was putting energy into maintaining relationships that weren't really growing with me. Eventually, I stopped engaging and let those relationships go. And honestly, I think that was probably for the best.

I don't see a particular reason why I would need to maintain those relationships today, but I do recognize that there's a certain loss in realizing that some people who were once such a significant part of your life aren't necessarily going to remain in it. I essentially “grew up” and spent my twenties with a core group of young women - living, traveling, working together for years side by side. And now none of them are a part of my life, with the exception of memories. That can feel sad at times.

Sometimes grief after leaving isn't about wanting to go back. It's simply recognizing that certain relationships, experiences, and parts of your life belonged to a chapter that has ended.

4. Finding Work and Building a Career After the Convent

This is one that I think deserves more conversation, particularly for women who spent a good number of years in religious life. When I first left, I really needed some recovery time. I became a Spanish and religion teacher at a Catholic school. I had always known teaching wasn't something I wanted to do forever, but it was a good first step.

I taught the special classes - Spanish & Religion - so there were not a lot of eyes on me or concern for my subjects, which helped the job feel light compared to homeroom or serious subject teachers. The schedule was nice - I was done by 3 p.m., had weekends & summers off. I also taught catechism to adults and children for a couple of years, so I wasn't completely free of responsibilities outside the school day.

But overall, teaching gave me some breathing room. I needed a job, and I needed time to recover. Teaching gave me that time.

Eventually, though, I started experiencing burnout from teaching, and then from subsequent jobs. I don't think all of my work struggles are directly related to having been a nun. But I do think there are some particular considerations for those of us who spent years in religious life.

For one, we may have missed some of the traditional working years. Depending on how long you were in, you may not have pursued a degree, developed a particular career path, or accumulated the work experience that other people your age have. I have a bachelor's degree in social work, which I don't intend to use, and that's pretty much where my formal education ended. I did not want to return to formal education post-convent. So there can be some practical gaps to navigate when you're trying to establish yourself professionally and support yourself financially.

There's also something I've noticed in conversations with other former religious women: many of us have a hard time with transactional work. We entered religious life because serving others, helping people, and doing meaningful work mattered to us. In our secular jobs, we still want to feel like we're using our gifts and contributing something valuable.

But sometimes the jobs that offer that sense of meaning don't pay particularly well. And sometimes those are the very jobs that can burn us out! (Like teaching, non-profits, counseling.) On the other hand, you could take a more transactional corporate job that pays well, offers benefits, and provides some financial stability, but leaves you feeling bored and disconnected from the work itself.

There's a balance to figure out.

  • How much meaning do you need from your work?

  • How much financial security do you need?

  • How much can you give without burning yourself out?

And then there's the question of whether you want to continue working within the Church or find something entirely outside of it. I've seen women navigate both paths.

For many women, transitioning from religious life to the secular workforce brings practical and emotional adjustments that can take years to navigate. I think work, career, and supporting yourself financially can continue to be an area of exploration and adjustment long after you've left the convent.

5. Processing Your Experience After Leaving Religious Life

This is probably the biggest piece I want to include because I think it's something that can take decades to move through.

Over the past 15 years, I've spoken with dozens of former sisters and women religious. Many have described their experiences in religious life, and particularly their departures, as traumatic to some extent. For some, the experiences were extremely severe. For others, perhaps less so. But there is often some degree of hurt, harm, manipulation, or overwhelm that needs to be processed.

I did a tremendous amount of processing during my first five years home. I wrote constantly. I started a Tumblr and shared all kinds of revelations and reflections about my experience. I journaled extensively. At one point, I even wrote a public letter to my former order, addressing my concerns about the community and my experiences with my superiors and sisters. That felt really good and was an important part of my own process. It still lives on the internet today and is how some former ssvm found me and our FB group.

Later, I got into somatic work, which helped me work through some of the overwhelm, burnout, and nervous system triggers I was still carrying from religious life. I would say that the processing and integrating of my experience took the better part of a decade. And I still recognize ways in which things that happened in the convent affect how I function today.

I think it's important to recognize that processing an experience like this isn't necessarily one big realization followed by moving on. There are layers to it. You might first recognize that something wasn't okay. Later, you might have language for it and begin to understand it as trauma, manipulation, or abuse. You might have to feel the anger, sadness, or disappointment that comes with that recognition. And then there's the process of integrating all of that into your life to the point where those things no longer trigger you.

I don't think there's a particular timeline for processing any of this. And I don't think being home for five, ten, or fifteen years necessarily means you've worked through everything. I know some sisters who left and never wanted to think or talk about their time in the convent again - they got married, had kids, moved on and didn’t even tell people in their life about it. Each soul has their journey. Sometimes you discover new layers as you get older, enter relationships, navigate work, or simply have more distance from the experience. That's been true for me.

We're Still Figuring It Out

I think there's something unique about being a former nun and walking around in the world as a lay person. There's a certain depth of experience that comes with having lived that life. A particular soul-level gravitas, almost, that I think is a beautiful part of our experience.

It's like having this really interesting piece of your story that most people don't know about. You carry all of that depth within you, and you can draw on it whenever you want or whenever a situation calls for it. And you can also just be grocery shopping on a Tuesday like a normal person. We are a rare breed!

I think it's important to remember that you don't have to make your former religious life the centerpiece of your identity. You also don't have to pretend it didn't happen. You get to decide how much of that story you share, how you relate to it, and how it fits into the life you're living now.

I wrote this particularly for those of us who have been home for a while and are still navigating life after leaving the convent. Those of us who were in during the early 2000s and 2010s, who have been out for a decade or more, and who are navigating the next chapters of our lives.

There are practical things to figure out: work, money, friendships, where to live, relationships, and all the ordinary decisions that come with building an adult life. And then there's the ongoing process of understanding what we experienced, how it shaped us, and what we want to carry forward.

I don't have all the answers. I'm still figuring some of it out myself. But I think there's value in having someone alongside you who understands at least some of what you've lived through. Therapists and priests and mentors can all be supportive and impactful in our journey, and yet if they were never a nun, there will always be a piece of that lived experience that they do not carry and we can feel that. I definitely have done my fair share of speaking with priests - both of my order and diocesan - post-convent, and therapists, some Christian, others not. And while all of them helped me along the way, some of the most validating experiences have been in my conversations with fellow ex-nuns. That’s just the truth of it!

Looking for a Space to Talk Through Your Own Experience?

That’s why I offer my 1:1 sessions for former nuns who have been out for awhile. Leaving religious life doesn't mean you stop being influenced by it. Whether you've been out for a few years or a few decades, there may be parts of your experience that continue to shape how you see yourself, make decisions, approach relationships, and navigate the world.

My one-on-one sessions offer a private, supportive space to bring whatever is happening in your life into a container held by someone who has been there - both inside the convent and back in the world.

A space to talk, explore, question, and find your way forward. I’d love to chat and hold space for you in this next season of your life.

Learn more here

If you’ve left religious life more recently and are in “phase one”, this video might be helpful for you - So You Left the Convent - My Top 5 Pieces of Advice

Next
Next

How to Break the Cycle of Burnout at Work: Why Your Body Needs a Seat at the Table